The dispute began before Attorney General Merrick Garland appointed Smith as special counsel last November, but appears to have continued under Smith’s auspices after he took over ongoing investigations into interference with the certification of 2020 election results.

Smith’s team could seek review of the decision by the full appeals court justices or by the Supreme Court. Tuesday’s decision may therefore not be the final word. A spokesperson for Smith had no immediate comment on the decision or whether prosecutors would seek further reconsideration.

Perry’s lawyers were in court on Tuesday morning for another case – the criminal trial of former Trump aide Peter Navarro – and were seen reading the ruling shortly after it was released. Although they declined to discuss specifics, the lawyers seemed optimistic about the outcome.

The new ruling is an important step for both Perry and the House of Representatives, which have sounded the alarm over prosecutors’ efforts to gain access to a congressman’s phone.

Notably, while the case was argued in February, it took more than six months for the appeals court to issue a decision. It’s a surprisingly long review period for a matter that seemed urgent to prosecutors – and one that suggests the panel engaged in careful scrutiny of the records at issue.

Although the appeals court’s 29-page ruling remains sealed, the three-judge panel said in court docket Tuesday that it partially overturned U.S. District Court Judge Beryl Howell’s ruling, which granted prosecutors access to most of the records seized from Perry’s phone. , blocking only a few dozen that she deemed beyond the reach of federal investigators.

Trump-appointed Judge Neomi Rao wrote the lead opinion for the appeals court, joined by President George HW Bush-appointed Judge Karen LeCraft Henderson. Judge Greg Katsas, also appointed by Trump, filed a six-page concurring opinion. The reasons for a possible disagreement between the judges were not immediately clear since the opinions remain sealed.

At issue is the courts’ interpretation of the Constitution’s “speak or debate” clause, which grants members of Congress immunity from criminal prosecution relating to their official work. Perry argued that much of what Smith’s team sought is protected by this constitutional provision and should be barred to prosecutors.

Howell, however, disagreed, saying Perry’s independent efforts to investigate voter fraud — and to report it to the executive branch — render those contacts unprotected by speaking or debating immunity.

The appeals court held a public hearing in the case after partially unsealing the case under the watchful eye of the media, but part of the discussion still remained secret.

During the discussion, a Justice Department lawyer now assigned to Smith’s office argued that the speech or debate protection only applies to investigations by lawmakers as part of an investigation. or formal investigation, not those they undertake themselves. Rao and Katsas seem to disagree, suggesting that the DOJ’s wording is too narrow and that there is at least some protection for individual members of Congress acting alone.

Perry told POLITICO in February that he was pleased with the appeals court’s decision to stay Howell’s decision while it considers the case.

In an order released Tuesday, the DC Circuit panel gave Perry’s attorneys and prosecutors one week to indicate whether they believe parts of the rulings should be kept secret.

The appeals court’s opinion will likely be scrutinized closely on Capitol Hill, where any interpretation of the speech or debate clause has huge implications for lawmakers.

House Democrats and Republicans united to intervene in Perry’s case — even without knowing the specifics of what prosecutors wanted Perry to do — to oppose any sweeping new rulings that would weaken lawmakers’ protections in the matter. speech or debate. The brief of the friend of the House court in this case remains under seal.

Asus ROG Phone 6 and ROG Phone 6 Pro: Update to Android 13 available

Nothing Phone (2): Should we finally expect a premium phone?

Why does Overwatch 2 need a postpaid phone number? Postpaid Phone Numbers, Explained

Alert on your phone: why your cell phone will ring very loudly this Friday morning if you are on the shores of the Mediterranean

Gcam: how to automatically have the best configuration for your phone thanks to XML files

How to change phone number on Samsung account

How To Know My Telcel Phone Number Without Balance

How do I disable Alice in Yandex Browser on my computer and on my phone?

Uncovering the Mysteries: Jio Phone 5G Images Sparked Interest

The Nothing Phone (2) will be available for pre-order in India soon.

Prepare to be surprised by the cost of the new Nothing Phone (2) in Europe!

The Nothing Phone (2) unveils a unique accessory!

Google Pixel 7a: 5 reasons to opt for this powerful and affordable phone

Upcoming Nothing Phone Update (1): What’s in store for Nothing OS 2.0?

The new leaks on the Nothing Phone (2) will surprise you!

Could the Nothing Phone 2 dethrone the Google Pixel with its innovative software?

Nothing Phone (2): OS updates up to Android 16

Comparison Google Pixel 7a vs Nothing Phone (1)

The revolution is underway: the Nothing Phone (2) is coming in July!

The Nothing Phone (2) promises an exceptional lifespan thanks to its 3 years of updates!

Emergency landing of a plane in Villejuif: the impressive composure of the pilot

With a salary of $212,000: the highest paid mayor in Quebec is… in Varennes

Mass killings are being carried out in Gaza and the world is just watching. This cannot continue | Houssam Zomlot

Admin, money and chatter: 6 essential articles for life in France

Blue Jays’ next steps after signing Shohei Ohtani with the Dodgers

Addicted to coffee? Why drinking your first cup on an empty stomach as soon as you wake up is not a good idea at all

Red Sea: The Languedoc multi-mission frigate shot down two hostile drones launched from Yemen

man seriously injured after exchange of fire with police

the voluntary commitments announced at the beginning of December are “far from sufficient”

Windblown, an indie hurricane from the creators of Dead Cells

The 4 Settings Every Pro Gamer Turns Off Immediately

Yemen’s Houthis warn they will target all Israel-bound ships in the Red Sea | Israeli-Palestinian conflict News

How much do your municipal elected officials earn?

Lakers win season tournament final behind Anthony Davis 41-20

Knife attack in Paris leaves one dead and others injured

Édouard Philippe “supports” the bill and proposes regularization “quotas”

Torrential rain: Half-extension for Heat approaches

LIVE – War in Ukraine: Ukrainians “in danger of death” without foreign aid, warns Olena Zelenska

Minister Aurore Bergé announces the establishment of a service of general interest for “failing parents”

“Let’s stop the madness”, Riolo no longer wants to see Mbappé in 9

Source : btimaging

Leave a Reply