Samsung is found guilty of infringing several Apple patents and must pay $1.05 billion.
A few days ago the demand continued between Samsung and Apple by infringing various patents. The end of all this discussion has finally come, the jury has determined in just three days of deliberations the Final verdict of the trial between Apple and Samsung. And the final verdict is that, among other things, Samsung has clearly infringed Apple’s patents on a number of mobile devices.
The devices in question (which include some variants of the same model) are the
- Samsung Captivate
- droid charge
- Epic 4G
- display 4G
- be fascinated
- Galaxy Ace
- Galaxy Prevail
- Galaxy S i9000
- Galaxy SII
- Galaxy S 4G
- Gem, Gravity
- Infuse 4G
- Nexus S 4G
- Transform and Vibrant, as well as the Galaxy Tab and Galaxy Tab 10.1 tablets.
In the case of the patent that describes the action of “pinch to zoom”, Of the 21 Samsung products contained in Apple’s lawsuit, all but three of them infringe the intellectual property of the company responsible for the iPhone and iPad. The jury has also found Samsung guilty of illegally copying the outline of the back of the iPhone and the graphical user interface of its home screens. family design Galaxy TabThe subject of bitter disputes throughout the world, it is nevertheless without sin, since the jury considers that it is not a copy of the iPad.
Most importantly and potentially serious for the South Koreans, the jury finds that Samsung executives knew that their products violated five of the seven patents listed by Apple, whose validity has also been upheld, dashing Samsung’s hope that they would be cancelled. As a resultSamsung must pay Apple compensation of 1,051 million dollars
Apple and Samsung have published their responses to the verdict, which can be summarized as “stealing is wrong” and “it is a disgrace for the consumer” respectively. We leave them below.
Apple’s response to the verdict:
We thank the jury for their service and for taking the time to listen to our story, we are excited to finally be able to tell it. The mountain of evidence presented during the process showed that the Samsung copies went much further than we knew. The lawsuits between Apple and Samsung were about something far more important than patents or money. They had to do with values. At Apple, we value originality and innovation and dedicate our lives to creating the best products on Earth. We make these products to delight our consumers, not for our competitors to blatantly copy. We applaud the court for finding that Samsung’s behavior was deliberate and for sending the message loud and clear that stealing is wrong.
Samsung’s response to the verdict:
Today’s verdict should not be seen as a win for Apple, but rather a loss for the American consumer. It will mean fewer options, less innovation, and potentially higher prices. It’s unfortunate that patent law can be manipulated to give a company a monopoly on rectangles with rounded corners or technologies that are being improved every day by Samsung and other companies. Consumers have the right to choose and know what they are buying when they purchase Samsung products. This is not the last word in this case or in battles in courts and tribunals around the world, some of which have already rejected many of Apple’s claims. Samsung will continue to innovate and offer consumer choice.
What do you think of all this war between Apple and Samsung. They agree with the judge’s decision. Tell me what you think in the comments.
Source: Engadget, The Wall Street Journal